Many people find case photos of an ideal nose on social media and feel hopeful that "this doctor might be able to make my ideal come true."
- Why case photos alone cannot measure a doctor's skill
- How doctors evaluate overall facial balance
- How patient concerns differ greatly between first-time rhinoplasty and revision surgery
- 5 perspectives to check when choosing a clinic
However, there are many cases where people judge by the beauty of case photos alone and later regret deformities or functional problems years later. In this article, based on revision-surgery data and medical evaluation criteria, we explain the key points of choosing a doctor to achieve long-term satisfying results.
Why you shouldn't judge a "skilled rhinoplasty doctor" by social media case photos alone
The immediately-post-op case photos posted on social media are, after all, no more than a snapshot of a single moment.
One post-operative complication is "contracture." This refers to a state in which the scar tissue from surgery hardens and shrinks, causing the nasal tip to point upward (short nose) or the skin to become tight. When a silicone implant is used, the capsule that forms around it becoming thick and hard is also a contributing factor. Infection, repeated surgeries, and excessive skin tension are risk factors, and it can progress over several months to several years. Because its frequency varies greatly by procedure and individual constitution, it can't be stated uniformly, but if you notice the following signs, consult the clinic where you had surgery right away.
Persistent redness or pain at the tip or bridge of the nose
The nasal tip feels harder than before
Over time, the nasal tip turns upward and the nostrils become more conspicuous
In a study by Hong et al., it was reported that among 87 people who underwent revision surgery for severe contracted nose, 19.5% had a history of past infection and 21.8% had undergone surgery two or more times.
tip plasty and augmentation rhinoplastythe materials used in such procedures (autologous cartilage, silicone, etc.) each have their own characteristics. Therefore, even if it looks beautiful right after surgery, you need to consider the possibility that such deformities may occur several months to several years later.
Unraveled from the reasons for revision surgery! Points where choosing a doctor easily goes wrong
In a study by Chauhan et al. surveying 400 rhinoplasty patients (308 first-time, 92 revision), the main dissatisfactions among first-time patients were intuitive ones such as "hump (dorsal bump: a protrusion of the bridge)" (50%) and "the nose is too big" (44%).
On the other hand, among patients who were dissatisfied with surgical results at other clinics and sought revision, the top complaint was "crooked nose" (38%), followed by "asymmetry of the nasal tip" (22%).
The same study reported that these occurred at significantly higher rates (P=0.001 and P=0.0001, respectively) compared with first-time patients.
The nose is made up of a complex combination of multiple parts—the nasal bones, the upper lateral cartilages, and the lower lateral cartilages (the cartilage that forms the shape of the tip). For example, if surgery changes the balance of the nose's internal structure, it may not withstand the contractile force of scar tissue produced during healing, and the nose maybecome crooked or asymmetrical.
Of course, post-operative deformity involves multiple factors—not only the initial design, but also the patient's own healing ability, post-operative infection, and unexpected trauma. Therefore, rather than just the immediate changes,a doctor who can propose a structure that is stable over the long term based on each individual's anatomical features—choosing one is an important criterion for avoiding regret.
Nose design is not just about "height." How doctors evaluate facial balance
In consultations, questions like "About how many millimeters higher will my nose be?" are often asked. In response, many doctors make proposals that consider not just height but overall facial balance.
So how is the design decided? One method is to refer to the objective proportions of the whole face.
When evaluating overall facial balance, doctors refer to objective indicators, but these are not absolute standards. For example, they may look at the balance between the alar width (the width of the nostrils) and the intercanthal distance (the distance between the eyes), but this is, after all, just one tendency that applies to many people. Because standards of beauty differ greatly by ethnicity and individual bone structure,doctors do not treat these numbers as absolute, but propose designs that prioritize your skin thickness, cartilage strength, and the harmony of your whole face.
Furthermore, multiple evaluation indicators exist—for instance, a tip projection (the height of the tip) of about 0.67 times the length of the nose (Goode's method) is considered well-balanced.
In addition, points such as a columella-to-tip ratio close to 2:1, or a columella width of about one-third of the base, are sometimes cited as conditions for a beautiful nose.
Angle is also an important factor. For example, the angle formed by the columella and the upper lip (nasolabial angle) is often guided at 95–105 degrees for women and 90–95 degrees for men. Many doctors refer to these multiple indicators while ultimately adjusting the design on a millimeter scale to fit each individual's bone structure and wishes.
Revealed by research data! The unexpected factor that affects post-operative satisfaction
Do you think "as long as I get a beautiful nose, I'll be fully satisfied"? In fact, the "functional aspect" is just as important as appearance. But it's not that simple.
In a study by Andrews et al., satisfaction at three months after surgery was evaluated in 121 patients who underwent septorhinoplasty, which includes functional aspects. The study reported that the SNOT-22 score (a 22-item questionnaire on nasal symptoms) used to evaluate post-operative QOL (quality of life) significantly improved from a pre-operative average of 48.6 to 26.6 at three months post-op (P < 0.0001). However, note that this data includes surgeries with functional aims such as improving nasal congestion, and the context differs from purely cosmetic surgery.
Inside the nose there are extremely narrow spaces called the "internal nasal valve" and "external nasal valve," which are the airways of the nasal cavity. Shaving away too much cartilage in an attempt to make the nose look narrower can cause serious nasal congestion, such as the nostrils collapsing inward with every inhalation.
This study suggests that, in addition to the cosmetic aspect, improvements in functional aspects such as ease of nasal breathing may also influence patient satisfaction.
There is also a study of 32 people that used techniques such as a caudal septal extension graft (a cartilage graft that extends the septum forward and downward) in correcting a crooked nose.
This report states that the deviation angle of the nasal dorsum (bridge) significantly approached the midline, from an average of 171.79 degrees to 175.51 degrees, and the nostril axis (the tilt of the nostrils) also decreased by 11.7 degrees, improving symmetry (P < 0.001).
In this way, balancing visual symmetry and functionis considered an important factor in increasing patient satisfaction.
"5 things to check" for choosing a clinic without regret
Based on the evidence so far, we have summarized into five the criteria for finding a trustworthy doctor and clinic. So, in practice, how should you check?
- Do they measure and analyze facial proportions on a millimeter scale?(Do they use objective indicators such as the distance between the eyes?)
- Do they make proposals that consider functional aspects such as post-operative "nasal breathing"?
- Do they provide data-based explanations of long-term risks such as infection and contracture?
- Do they have advanced skill and knowledge not only for first-time surgery but also for revision of other clinics' work (correcting asymmetry and crookedness)?
- Do they look ahead not only to right after surgery but to the long-term course of several months to several years later?
In a consultation, it is important to choose a doctor who, after you convey your ideal, gives concrete explanations—based on medical evidence—of what is possible and what is difficult.
The beauty of case photos is one piece of reference information. What you should really check is whether the doctor has anatomical knowledge and makes proposals that also consider function. That is the key to achieving long-term satisfying results.
If you're wondering, "What about my case?"
Book a free consultation
There is no pushy sales pressure. Please feel free to reach out.
Summary of this article
- If you choose based only on the immediate post-op beauty in case photos, it's hard to notice problems like crookedness or asymmetry later
- Many doctors evaluate overall facial balance such as the intercanthal distance, and propose a nose design tailored to individual features
- In addition to the nose's appearance, functional aspects such as post-operative "ease of breathing" may affect satisfaction
- Treat millimeter-level figures (the golden ratio) as merely reference information; it's important to choose a clinic that concretely explains the risks and design limits tailored to your individual features
If you have questions or concerns about rhinoplasty, first receive a consultation at a specialist clinic and hear a detailed explanation.
References
- Hong D, Oh J, Wang J, et al. A Grading System-Guided Approach to the Severely Contracted Nose. Aesthetic Plastic Surgery. 2024 (DOI)
- Chauhan N, Alexander A, Sepehr A, et al. Patient Complaints With Primary Versus Revision Rhinoplasty: Analysis and Practice Implications. Aesthetic Surgery Journal. 2011 (DOI)
- Rohrich R, Savetsky I, Suszynski T, et al. Systematic Surgical Approach to Alar Base Surgery in Rhinoplasty. Plastic & Reconstructive Surgery. 2020 (DOI)
- Boustany A, Grover R, Alnaeem H, et al. Cosmetic Rhinoplasty. Plastic & Reconstructive Surgery. 2023 (DOI)
- Andrews P, Choudhury N, Takhar A, et al. The need for an objective measure in septorhinoplasty surgery: are we any closer to finding an answer?. Clinical Otolaryngology. 2015 (DOI)
- Chen K, Kondra K, Nagengast E, et al. Syndromic Synostosis. Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery Clinics of North America. 2022 (DOI)
About the author
Tetsu Shaku Physician
Chairman, SUNSET Medical Corporation — Zetith Beauty Clinic Ginza, Osaka, Fukuoka
He specializes in rhinoplasty grounded in anatomical evidence, with an annual case volume among the top in the industry. He is known for procedure designs that emphasize structural support and an approach that pursues long-term stability.