How long the effect of nasal tip refinement lasts is honestly difficult to definitively conclude based on research[1]. However, research suggests that creating a foundation with cartilage rather than tightening with thread makes it easier to maintain the height of the nasal tip for longer[2][3]. Let us organize what is understood and what is not.
How long do changes to the nasal tip last?
In a review of multiple studies dealing with nasal tip grafting (cartilage transplantation), satisfactory results are said to be achieved with both autologous tissue and synthetic materials.[1] On the other hand, it is explicitly stated that determining which method is truly superior and how long its effects last remains difficult today.[1] There are still many unconfirmed aspects regarding durability.
Does the thread-tightening method experience relapse easily?
Textbooks state that Asian noses often have thick skin and weak cartilage, making it difficult to sufficiently change the shape of the nasal tip by thread-tightening alone.[3] This is because the cartilage is pushed back by skin tension, which can result in loss of height.[2] For this reason, cartilage grafting is positioned as an important component of nasal tip refinement[3]。
Is it easier to maintain the result when building a foundation with cartilage?
To maintain the height of the nose tip for a long time, the idea of adding structural support is emphasized[4]。Methods such as extending the nasal septal cartilage to create a foundation (Septal extension rhinoplasty) are representative examples[5]。Textbooks also emphasize that for Asian noses, the surgical technique should be chosen with long-term stability in mind[4]。
What are the limitations revealed by research?
There are honest limitations we should keep in mind. Currently, high-quality research directly comparing surgical techniques over the long term is still limited, and it is difficult to present the frequency of regression as a single standard figure[1]。The way the nose tip changes is greatly influenced by individual differences such as skin thickness and cartilage strength[2]。
What to confirm during consultation
What we want to confirm is whether there are factors in your own nose that make it prone to regression, whether thread alone is sufficient or if foundation reinforcement is needed, and the design of the support to maintain the result long-term[2][3][4]。Skin thickness and cartilage strength are difficult to self-assess from the outside. Having a physician examine your nose tip condition and aligning the reasons for the surgical technique, including ease of maintenance, is the starting point.
- 1Skochdopole A et al. Nasal Tip Grafts: A Systematic Review of Techniques and Outcomes. Plastic Surgery Review. 2023.
- 2Suh MK. Atlas of Asian Rhinoplasty. 2018. Section on Nasal tip skin and tip projection.
- 3Suh MK. Atlas of Asian Rhinoplasty. 2018. Section on Nasal tip skin and tip projection.
- 4Suh MK. Atlas of Asian Rhinoplasty. 2018. Section on Nasal tip skin and tip projection.
- 5Namgoong S, Yoon Y, Park S, Suh MK. A Comparative Study of Septal Extension Graft versus Derotation Graft for Short Nose Correction in Asian Rhinoplasty. Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery. 2025. doi:10.1097/PRS.0000000000012022